Fiducie practice — Art collection & transfer

Fiducie for an art collection:
protect, manage, transfer

The fiducie (Civil Code art. 2011 to 2030) is a powerful wealth tool for art collectors: protection against creditors, organisation of custody and insurance, financing backed by the value of the works, preparation of the transfer. Combined with the dedicated tax mechanisms (dation in payment Tax Code 1131, gift to museums Tax Code 794, flat tax Tax Code 150 VI to VM), the fiducie makes it possible to durably structure a private collection or a family art trust.

Discuss a collection Back to the Fiducie hub
Paris · Geneva · Marseille · Cannes · Lisbon
— In brief
Governing texts
Civil Code art. 2011 to 2030 + Law of 19 February 2007
Tax regime
Tax Code 238 quater A to I, neutrality
Flat tax
Tax Code 150 VI to VM, 6.5% or the ordinary regime (capital gains 19% + social levies 17.2%)
Dation in payment
Tax Code 1131, payment of transfer duties through the handover of works of art
Gift to museums
Tax Code 794, exemption where the gift is made to a State or approved museum
— 01

Art requires a specific wealth structure

An art collection of significant value raises issues that classic wealth tools resolve only imperfectly: physical conservation (specialised warehouses, free ports), insurance (specific policies, periodic appraisal), management (loans to museums, exhibitions, occasional sales), transfer (family co-ownership as a source of conflict, complexity of valuation for transfer duties).

Our conviction: the management fiducie (Civil Code art. 2018, in its version after Law 2008-776) is an ideal tool to durably structure a family collection. It makes it possible to: (a) appoint a competent fiduciary (often a fiduciary lawyer or a dedicated company), (b) organise custody and conservation according to precise contractual rules, (c) preserve the collection from family dispersal or wealth hazards, (d) facilitate the progressive transfer to heirs through the designated-beneficiary mechanism.

A crucial limitation: the fiducie cannot serve as a gift (Civil Code art. 2013), so it does not replace the donation or the legacy. It complements these mechanisms by framing the intermediate management, and makes it possible to combine the collection with the dedicated tax tools (dation, gift to museums, flat tax).

— 03

A case study handled by the firm

Private collection of €18M, management fiducie + progressive transfer plan

A collector aged 72, a modern and contemporary art collection (250 works, value €18M), 3 children of whom only 1 is interested in art, a transfer issue. Our architecture: (1) a management fiducie over 200 works for the benefit of the collector (settlor and beneficiary) with a dedicated fiduciary lawyer, tasked with conservation + management of loans to museums + insurance, (2) a gift in full ownership of 30 works (~€3.5M) to the interested child using the Tax Code 779 allowance (€100k) + progressive payment of transfer duties over 10 years, (3) a dation undertaking upon death covering 15 major works (~€7M) pre-approved by the interministerial commission, (4) a gift to museums of 5 difficult works (low market value but scientific interest), leading to exemption under Tax Code 794 + patronage reduction. Outcome: an organised transfer, controlled taxation, a preserved collection. Cost of setting up the fiducie: ~€75k + annual fiduciary fees ~€25k.

— 02

4 operational mechanics for collections

1. Family management fiducie (“art trust”)

The collection is transferred to a fiduciary who ensures its custodial management on behalf of the settlor and the heirs. Advantages: (a) continuity of management beyond successions, (b) professionalisation (insurance, conservation, loans to museums), (c) protection against dispersal. Terms: a detailed agreement setting out the fiduciary's powers (loan authorisation, annual disposal ceiling, oversight right of the settlor and the heirs).

2. Security fiducie for financing backed by the collection

Several private banks (Edmond de Rothschild, Pictet, Mirabaud) offer credit backed by works of art with an LTV ratio of 30 to 50%. The security fiducie over the works makes it possible to secure such credit: the bank can be assured that the works will not be sold, moved or disposed of without its agreement. A neutral tax regime (Tax Code 238 quater A to I), no taxable triggering event.

3. Combining the fiducie with the dation in payment (Tax Code 1131)

On a succession, the heirs may pay the transfer duties on gratuitous transfers through the handover of works of art to the State (Tax Code art. 1131). The dation mechanism is supervised by the interministerial approval commission. The fiducie can be used upstream to pre-select the works intended for the dation, to keep them in optimal conditions until death, and to coordinate the valuation with the commission.

4. Gift to museums and exemption under Tax Code 794

The gift of works to a State museum, an approved public museum or a public institution entails full exemption from transfer duties (Tax Code art. 794). The fiducie can structure the donation in several stages (gift with reserved usufruct, long-term loan with an undertaking to give, and so on). For works given during one's lifetime, combination with the patronage tax reduction (Tax Code 200 bis and 238 bis AB).

— Frequently asked questions

Can a fiducie replace a foreign trust for a collection?

Yes for collections held mainly in France and by a settlor who is a French tax resident. The French fiducie has the advantage of full recognition by the French authorities (vs a foreign trust subject to the 2181-Trust filings and to the regime of art. 792-0 bis). For collections held abroad or by a non-resident settlor, the foreign trust often remains preferable, so a comparative analysis is indispensable.

Can the fiducie organise conservation and insurance?

Yes, this is even one of its major strengths. The fiducie contract sets out the fiduciary's obligations: conservation in specialised warehouses (Geneva or Singapore free ports, for example), taking out dedicated insurance policies (Hiscox, AXA Art, Bessé), periodic appraisals, authorisations for loans to museums. The professionalisation of management is one of the main advantages over personal or co-ownership management.

How does the fiducie interact with the 6.5% flat tax on disposal?

On a disposal of a work by the fiduciary (for the benefit of a third party or a transfer back to the settlor followed by a sale), it is the situation of the effective seller (the beneficiary of the fiducie) that determines the tax regime. If the beneficiary is the settlor and a natural person, they may opt for the 6.5% flat tax (Tax Code 150 VI to VM, applicable to disposals of precious objects > €5,000) or the ordinary regime (capital gains 19% + social levies 17.2% with an allowance for the holding period).

Can the collection travel (loans to museums) under a fiducie?

Yes, provided the fiducie contract expressly so provides. The availability agreement or the fiduciary's powers must authorise loans to museums (with “nail-to-nail” insurance, a strictly defined loan agreement, a limited duration). This flexibility is precisely one of the advantages of the fiducie over raw succession co-ownership.

Cité par

An art collection to structure?

A confidential initial consultation, audit of the collection, fiducie + dation + donation + transfer scenarios, coordination with experts, insurers and a dedicated fiduciary.

Request an appointment See the Art practice
Jonathan Bensaid, avocat fondateur

Written by

Me Jonathan Bensaid, avocat fiscaliste, fondateur du cabinet Bensaid Avocats, inscrit aux Barreaux de Paris & Genève.

© BENSAID Avocats — The information on this site does not constitute legal advice and cannot replace a personalised tax and legal analysis.