Fiducie practice — Cross-cutting comparison

French fiducie vs Swiss fiduciaire

A frequent terminological confusion that can have significant consequences for your search for advice. In France, the term "fiduciaire" refers to a legal mechanism for transferring ownership (Civil Code, art. 2011 et seq.), whereas in Switzerland it means a chartered accountant. Two professions, two logics: an essential clarification.

Paris · Geneva · Marseille · Cannes · Lisbon
— 01

Why this confusion is problematic

Looking for a "fiduciaire in Geneva" in order to obtain a French security fiducie will lead you to Swiss chartered accountants who do not practise this legal mechanism. Conversely, engaging a lawyer specialised in the French fiducie to keep your Swiss accounts will be a waste of time on both sides.

The two professions use similar terms but carry out completely different roles. The Swiss fiduciaire is a certified professional (the equivalent of the French chartered accountant) who handles accounting, taxation and company administration. The French fiducie is a legal mechanism for transferring ownership, governed by the Civil Code, used to secure a financing or organise wealth management.

BENSAID Avocats acts exclusively on the French-law fiducie. For Swiss accounting needs, we refer clients to partner fiduciaires in Geneva, and we work with them regularly on cross-border matters.

— 02

Detailed comparison: France vs Switzerland

01

The fiduciaire in Switzerland

A regulated accounting profession. The equivalent of the French chartered accountant. This profession does not exist under French law by that name.

  • Accounting and bookkeeping
  • Preparation of annual accounts
  • Swiss tax filings
  • Tax advice and optimisation
  • Company domiciliation
  • Company administration
  • Advice on company formation
02

The fiducie in France

A legal mechanism for transferring ownership, governed by the Civil Code. Does NOT exist under Swiss law.

  • A contract governed by the French Civil Code (art. 2011 et seq.)
  • Transfer of ownership of assets to a fiduciary
  • Creation of a dedicated pool of assets
  • Administration according to a defined mission
  • Purpose of security or management
  • Used for complex financings
  • Sophisticated wealth structuring
03

Comparison table — Criteria

Fundamental differences between the two concepts.

  • Nature — CH: profession / service provider · FR: legal mechanism / contract
  • Applicable law — CH: Swiss law · FR: French law (Civil Code)
  • Main activity — CH: accounting & taxation · FR: transfer of ownership & wealth management
  • Equivalent — CH: French chartered accountant · FR: common-law trust (a close concept)
  • Who may act? — CH: certified Swiss professionals · FR: lawyers, credit institutions, insurers
  • Typical purpose — CH: administrative and tax management · FR: financing security, complex wealth management
04

What BENSAID Avocats does

We act exclusively on the French-law fiducie.

  • Structuring of security fiducies to secure financings
  • Fiduciary administration as a fiduciary lawyer
  • Management fiducies for the administration of complex assets
  • Tax advice on the French fiducie (VAT, transfer duties, corporate tax)
  • Drafting of fiducie contracts and related documentation
  • France – Switzerland cross-border structures using the French fiducie
  • No Swiss accounting, taxation or company administration
— 03

Our cross-border practice

Geneva office: coordination of France–Switzerland transactions, with the French fiducie as a structuring tool.

France – Switzerland coordination

Our Geneva office allows us to support transactions involving parties or assets located in Switzerland, while using the French-law fiducie as a structuring tool. We work regularly with Swiss fiduciaires (chartered accountants) on the Swiss accounting and tax aspects, while handling the legal aspects of the French fiducie ourselves.

Three examples of cross-border matters

Financing by a Swiss bank of a French asset

Structuring of a French security fiducie to secure the loan, coordination with the Geneva bank and Swiss counsel.

Swiss family office holding assets in France

Setting up a French management fiducie, liaison with the Swiss fiduciaire (accountant) for the family office's consolidated reporting.

France – Switzerland debt restructuring

Use of the French fiducie as a tool to secure creditors, coordination with Swiss creditors and counsel on both sides of the border.

— 04

Lead counsel — France-Switzerland coordination

The firm's France – Switzerland cross-border practice is led by Jonathan Bensaid (founding partner, admitted to the Paris and Geneva Bars) and Lauren Bensaid (Banking & Finance partner), together with a network of partner fiduciaires in Geneva for the Swiss accounting aspects.

  • Civil Code article 2011
  • French fiducie
  • France-Switzerland coordination
  • Geneva office
  • Partner fiduciaires CH
  • Paris · Geneva · Marseille · Cannes · Lisbon
— 05

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a French fiducie and a Swiss fiduciaire?

The French fiducie is a legal mechanism for transferring ownership (Civil Code art. 2011 et seq.) used to secure a financing or organise wealth management. The Swiss fiduciaire is a regulated accounting profession (the equivalent of the French chartered accountant). Two entirely distinct concepts.

Does the term "fiduciaire" have the same meaning in France and in Switzerland?

No. In France, the "fiduciaire" refers to the person who temporarily holds an asset under a fiducie contract. In Switzerland, the "fiduciaire" refers to a chartered accountant and tax adviser. These are two different roles that happen to share a similar term.

Can you keep my Swiss accounts?

No. BENSAID Avocats acts exclusively on the French-law fiducie. For Swiss bookkeeping, Swiss tax filings or the administration of Swiss companies, we refer you to partner fiduciaires in Geneva.

Can you structure a fiducie for a Swiss client?

Yes, provided the fiducie is created under French law (for example, to secure a financing over French assets, or to organise the management of French assets for a Swiss settlor). See our examples of cross-border matters.

Is there an equivalent of the French fiducie under Swiss law?

Swiss law does not recognise the fiducie in the sense of the French Civil Code. Other tools exist (fiduciary mandates, holding structures, foundations) that may play functionally similar roles, but their legal regime is different. The closest concept remains the common-law trust.

Cité par

A France-Switzerland transaction in prospect?

Present the context (parties, jurisdictions, assets, purpose), so we can assess whether the French fiducie is the relevant tool and arrange an initial consultation.

Jonathan Bensaid, avocat fondateur

Written by

Me Jonathan Bensaid, avocat fiscaliste, fondateur du cabinet Bensaid Avocats, inscrit aux Barreaux de Paris & Genève.