Real-estate VAT · Ministerial answer of 27 October 2026

Purchase option under a property lease, then immediate resale: which VAT applies when Article 257 bis does not?

A lessee under a French real-estate finance lease (crédit-bail immobilier) exercises the purchase option on a building completed more than five years ago and resells it the same day to its sub-tenant, who holds it as stock or occupies it. Neither the option exercise nor the resale is relieved from VAT. The answer published in the National Assembly Official Journal on 27 October 2026 sets out the treatment of the two successive sales: the lessee deducts nothing, but may transfer nineteen twentieths of the VAT to its purchaser, provided the purchaser records the building as a fixed asset.

Paris · Geneva · Marseille · Cannes · Lisbon

Which VAT applies to a purchase option followed by an immediate resale to a sub-purchaser that does not meet the conditions of Article 257 bis?

The option exercise is not relieved from VAT: the lessee resells the building without operating it. If the lessor elects to tax the sale, the lessee cannot deduct the VAT charged, since its own resale is exempt; if the lessor does not elect, the lessor adjusts the VAT it had deducted and gives the lessee a certificate, which gives the lessee no right of deduction.

In both cases, the lessee may give its purchaser a certificate transferring the right to deduct 19/20ths of the VAT, provided the purchaser records the building as a fixed asset; the purchaser will deduct that VAT only to the extent it uses the building for transactions giving a right of deduction. The remaining twentieth, for the year of the option exercise, cannot be transferred.

Written question No. 16090 by Mr Thierry Liger (JO AN, 16 June 2026, p. 5361) and answer of the Ministry of Public Action and Accounts (JO AN, 27 October 2026, p. 10048): full text on assemblee-nationale.fr (in French); CGI, Annex II, Art. 207. Checked on 28 October 2026.

— In brief
Text
Ministerial answer to written question No. 16090 (National Assembly), JO AN of 27 October 2026, p. 10048
Article 257 bis
Does not apply to the option exercise when the lessee immediately resells to a sub-purchaser that does not continue the taxed letting
Taxed option
By election of the lessor (CGI, Art. 260, 5° bis): VAT not deductible by the lessee
Exempt option
Adjustment by the lessor and certificate to the lessee (CGI, Annex II, Art. 207, III)
Resale
Exempt; certificate for 19/20ths to the sub-purchaser, if it records the building as a fixed asset
— 02 · The provisions

The four provisions the answer combines

The answer creates no new rule: it applies existing provisions to a chain of two sales. Here they are, as in force on 28 October 2026.

  • The relief (CGI, Art. 257 bis). On the transfer, for consideration, free of charge or as a contribution to a company, of all or part of a totality of assets between persons liable to VAT, no supply of goods or services is deemed to take place. The transferee is treated as the successor of the transferor (text, in French).
  • Exemption and election (CGI, Art. 261, 5, 2° and 260, 5° bis). Supplies of buildings completed more than five years ago are exempt; those making them may, on request, pay VAT (Art. 261; Art. 260).
  • The adjustment period (CGI, Annex II, Art. 207, II, 3). For buildings held as fixed assets, adjustments are made by one twentieth over twenty years. For buildings let under a finance lease, the period is the number of years until the lease expires, rounded up, capped at twenty. That rule specific to leasing concerns the lessor; the lessee that becomes owner falls under the ordinary period.
  • Global adjustment and transfer (CGI, Annex II, Art. 207, III, 1, 2 and 3). The sale of a fixed asset not subject to VAT triggers an adjustment for the remaining years. The transferee, provided the asset is also a fixed asset in its hands, may deduct, under the ordinary rules (Art. 206), a fraction of the original VAT equal to the ratio of the remaining years to the total period; the transferor issues a certificate for that purpose. The mechanism does not apply to sales relieved under Article 257 bis (III, 4, 1°).
  • Administrative guidance. Holding the building as stock normally prevents the transfer; treatment as a fixed asset (Art. 207, IV, 3) requires that, at 31 December of the second year after completion, the building has been used for more than one year for an economic activity, which rules it out on an immediate resale (BOI-TVA-IMM-10-30, § 390); the content of the certificate and the 2018 rulings on leasing are in BOI-TVA-DED-60-20-10, § 240 and 286.
— 03 · Before the courts

Three decisions on the resale that follows the option

The same-day question is not new. The administrative courts have ruled on the relief, the civil courts on the drafting of the deeds.

  • An immediate resale does not rule out the relief if the purchaser continues the letting. For a lessee that had exercised the option and resold the same day, relying on the judgment of the Court of Justice of 27 November 2003 (C-497/01), the Conseil d'État held that the relief applies where the transferee intends to operate the business transferred rather than liquidate it immediately; the speed of the resale was not enough to deny it, the purchaser having continued the letting (CE, 23 November 2015, No. 375054).
  • Same solution, same day. In a related case, where the acquisition from the lessor had itself been relieved, the Conseil d'État set aside the judgment on the same ground (CE, 23 November 2015, No. 375055). Both decisions underpin the guidance adopted in 2018 (BOI-TVA-DED-60-20-10, § 286).
  • The clause in the deed makes the difference. A deed of option exercise, followed by a same-day resale, applied the relief from adjustment with no recourse for the lessor if the tax authorities rejected it. The lessor having paid the adjustment, the Cour de cassation upheld the court of appeal's finding that no clause put that sum on the lessee. The judgment does not rule on Article 257 bis; it shows the price of a poorly built clause (Cass. 1re civ., 12 May 2016, No. 15-19.779).
— 04 · Recodification

From 1 January 2027, which CIBS articles?

The answer reasons on the CGI. On 1 January 2027, only the legislative VAT provisions move into the Code of taxes on goods and services (Ordinance No. 2026-671 of 27 July 2026): Article 207 of Annex II remains applicable until repealed, and ministerial answers not withdrawn remain binding, references to the CGI included (BOI-RES-TVA-000253 of 7 October 2026, § 2.1 and 2.2). The new legislative framework is in Articles L. 223-35, L. 223-39 and L. 223-40: a supply that transfers the right to dispose of the asset is a "reallocation"; where it gives no right of deduction and the recipient is a taxable person for whom the asset is a capital good, the supplier's "residual tax" is deemed borne by the recipient; the year of reallocation remains with the supplier (L. 223-30). Two provisions call for caution for a lessee that resells without operating: Article L. 223-23 disapplies the capital-goods rules, except Article L. 223-22, to an asset that loses that status "before being actually used", and Article L. 223-40 then provides that the residual tax is deductible under the rules for other goods and services. No guidance yet settles how they interact: an option exercised from 1 January 2027 deserves to be secured by a ruling.

According to the official concordance table of 28 July 2026, the election becomes Article L. 231-15, the exemption Article L. 231-17, the leasing-specific period Article L. 231-32 and the relief Article L. 211-108, the notion of totality of assets giving way to the transfer of an autonomous economic activity (L. 211-107). Deeds signed from 2027 should refer to these articles (see the recodification of French real-estate VAT).

— 05 · Lease or sale

Will a real-estate finance lease still be a letting after 1 January 2027?

The whole reasoning of the ministerial answer assumes that the finance lease is a letting, followed by a sale when the option is exercised. In the CGI, treating the handover of the asset as an immediate supply applies only to tangible movable property let under a contract with a clause providing that ownership is normally acquired by the holder at the latest on payment of the last instalment (CGI, Art. 256, II, 3°, c).

Article L. 211-36 of the CIBS, applicable from 1 January 2027, is drafted more broadly: "Where a transfer of ownership is deferred until full payment of the consideration, the supply of goods is deemed to take place when the goods are physically handed over. Such a deferral includes the acquisition of ownership upon payment of the last instalment of a contract making the asset available, where that acquisition results automatically from the terms of the contract or from the absence of an economically rational alternative choice" (Ordinance No. 2026-671 of 27 July 2026, annex; unofficial translation). The text does not distinguish movable from immovable property. Where the option price is far below the expected value of the building at the end of the term, the financial terms of the contract as a whole may make exercising the option the only economically rational decision. The tax authorities could then argue that the building was supplied when it was physically handed over to the lessee, not when the option was exercised; the rules for supplies of buildings would apply at that date. The assessment is global: the ratio between the option price and the rents paid is not enough on its own.

Administrative guidance takes the opposite view. Since 8 July 2026, the BOFiP states that the handover of an asset, "whether movable tangible property or immovable property", under a finance lease or a lease with a purchase option "is not regarded as a supply of goods". These contracts, in particular those governed by Articles L. 313-7 et seq. of the Monetary and Financial Code, are a letting with a "mere option to purchase", the transaction being a letting followed, where applicable, by a supply when the option is exercised (BOI-TVA-CHAMP-10-10-40-10, § 100).

This guidance can still be relied on after the recodification. Section III of Article 46 of Ordinance No. 2025-1247 of 17 December 2025, as inserted by the Ordinance of 27 July 2026, provides that, for the purposes of Articles L. 64 B, L. 80 A and L. 80 B of the Tax Procedures Code, the authorities' interpretation of CGI provisions transferred into the CIBS constitutes an interpretation of the corresponding CIBS provisions (text). Article L. 80 A bars any reassessment based on an interpretation different from the one the authorities had published and not withdrawn at the date of the transactions. The authorities drew the consequences on 7 October 2026: all their guidance not withdrawn or lapsed before 1 January 2027 remains binding from that date (BOI-RES-TVA-000253, § 2.1). A theoretical reservation remains: Section III of Article 46 covers the interpretation of provisions transferred from the CGI, and the second sentence of Article L. 211-36 had no counterpart in the CGI for buildings.

  • Review the contract. Automatic acquisition at the end of the term, an obligation to purchase or a penalty for not exercising the option move the lease away from the "mere option to purchase" described in the guidance.
  • Document the option price. Keep what justifies it (residual value, expected value of the building at the end of the term, term, rents) and what shows that exercising the option remains a real choice for the lessee.
  • Secure significant transactions. The authorities have not yet commented on Article L. 211-36: where the building is to be handed over to the lessee on or after 1 January 2027, a ruling requested before the handover remains the safest protection.
— 01

What did the member of parliament ask, and what does the Government answer?

A building completed more than five years ago is let under a finance lease, with rents subject to VAT. The lessee sub-lets it with VAT, exercises the option early, records the building as a fixed asset and resells it the same day to its sub-tenant, which does not meet the conditions of Article 257 bis of the French Tax Code (CGI): it holds the building as stock or occupies it itself. The resale is exempt: the lessee could elect for VAT, but the election is described as impracticable given the tax the purchaser would have to fund.

The member of parliament asked for confirmation that the lessee could deduct the VAT on the option exercise, then issue a certificate while keeping one twentieth. The answer does not follow that reading. Article 257 bis does not apply to the sale from lessor to lessee, as the lessee keeps the building "without operating it" and resells it at once. Two scenarios are then distinguished.

Option price taxed by election of the lessor. The lessee, whose resale is exempt, is "not entitled to make any deduction" of the VAT charged. As the building is a fixed asset in its hands, that VAT enters a twenty-year adjustment period, the year of acquisition included. The exempt resale allows it to transfer the right of deduction to its purchaser, provided the purchaser also records the building as a fixed asset, up to 19/20ths.

Option price exempt. The lessor, which had deducted the VAT on the acquisition or construction, adjusts the VAT for the remaining years and gives the lessee a certificate. That VAT is not deductible by the lessee, but it opens a new twenty-year period in its hands. On the resale, the lessee in turn issues a certificate equal to 19/20ths of the amount shown on the lessor's certificate.

The answer complements the one given to Mr Romain Grau (JO AN, 10 July 2018, No. 7359), without calling it into question. In 2018, the authorities accepted that both successive sales qualify for the relief when the final purchaser records the building as a fixed asset and continues the taxed letting, and refused it when the purchaser holds it as stock. The 2026 answer deals with that second case, and with the owner-occupier purchaser.

— 06

What to provide for before signing the two deeds

The answer secures the tax treatment. It leaves the parties to allocate the cost of the twentieth and to evidence the conditions.

Qualify the sub-purchaser first

Everything depends on how the final purchaser will account for the building. If it records a fixed asset and continues the taxed letting, the relief applies to both sales; if it records a fixed asset to occupy the building, the 2026 answer applies, its deduction depending on its own transactions; if it holds stock for resale, no certificate is possible and the VAT is not transferred; its economic burden is a matter for the contract.

Quantify the twentieth and price it in

The non-transferable twentieth is a final cost for the lessee. For 100 of VAT charged on the option, or shown on the lessor's certificate, the certificate given to the sub-purchaser covers 95. With a taxed option price, the remaining 5 are VAT paid by the lessee and not recoverable; with an exempt option price, they are a non-transferred fraction of the VAT adjusted by the lessor, whose economic burden is a matter for the contract. Prices should reflect it.

Draft the two certificates

The certificate states the deductible amount, the identity of the parties, the description of the property, its acquisition date and the date of sale (BOI-TVA-DED-60-20-10, § 240). With an exempt option price, two are needed: from lessor to lessee, and from lessee to sub-purchaser.

Provide for recourse if challenged

The option deed should state who bears an adjustment if the analysis is challenged, and the resale deed should contain the sub-purchaser's undertaking to record the building as a fixed asset. The 2016 judgment shows the cost of silence.

— 07

Our approach

The firm advises before real-estate lease option exercises, alongside lessees, purchasers and their notaries: choice between relief, taxed option and exempt option, calculation of adjustments, drafting of clauses and certificates.

In tax audits, we defend operators whose treatment is challenged, relying on the administrative guidance and the ministerial answers that protect the transaction.

— Diagram

The two successive sales and the transfer of 19/20ths

From lessor to sub-purchaser, depending on whether the option price is taxed by election or exempt.

Diagram of a purchase option under a French real-estate finance lease followed by an immediate resale outside Article 257 bis: the lessor sells to the lessee either with VAT by election, not deductible by the lessee, or exempt with an adjustment and a certificate; the lessee resells exempt to the sub-purchaser and gives it a certificate for 19/20ths of the VAT if the sub-purchaser records the building as a fixed asset, the last twentieth not being transferable.
Branch A: option price taxed by election of the lessor (CGI, Art. 260, 5° bis). Branch B: exempt option price (CGI, Art. 261, 5, 2°), adjustment by the lessor and certificate. In both branches, the exempt resale allows the transfer of 19/20ths to a sub-purchaser that records the building as a fixed asset (CGI, Annex II, Art. 207, III, 3).
— FAQ

Purchase option and resale: your questions

From 2027, will a real-estate finance lease be a supply from the outset?

That is not the authorities' position. If its conditions were met, Article L. 211-36 of the CIBS would deem the supply to take place when the building is physically handed over to the lessee, where final acquisition results automatically from the contract or from the absence of an economically rational alternative choice. But the BOFiP of 8 July 2026 maintains that handing over a building under a finance lease is not a supply: it is a letting followed, where applicable, by a supply when the option is exercised (BOI-TVA-CHAMP-10-10-40-10, § 100). The authorities confirmed on 7 October 2026 that their guidance not withdrawn remains binding after 1 January 2027 (BOI-RES-TVA-000253, § 2.1; Ordinance No. 2025-1247, Art. 46, III; Tax Procedures Code, Art. L. 80 A). An automatic transfer or an option price far below the expected value of the building justify a ruling before the handover.

Can the lessee deduct the VAT charged on the option exercise?

No, where its resale is exempt. Under the answer of 27 October 2026, it is "not entitled to make any deduction". It may however transfer 19/20ths of that VAT to its purchaser by certificate, if the purchaser records the building as a fixed asset; the purchaser deducts it according to its own right of deduction (CGI, Annex II, Art. 207, III, 3).

What if the sub-purchaser holds the building as stock?

The resale does not qualify for Article 257 bis (Grau answer of 10 July 2018), nor does the option exercise (answer of 27 October 2026). The transfer of the right of deduction requires a fixed asset in the purchaser's hands: holding the building as stock from the outset prevents it (BOI-TVA-IMM-10-30, § 390). With a taxed option price, the VAT charged remains non-deductible for the lessee, unless its resale is taxed by election; with an exempt option price, the VAT adjusted by the lessor cannot be passed on, and its economic burden is a matter for the contract.

Why 19/20ths and not the full amount?

The lessee's period counts twenty years, including the year of acquisition; as the option and the resale occur in the same year, nineteen remain.

Cité par

Prepare the option exercise and the resale, reply within 24 business hours