Trusts and criminal seizure: being a beneficial owner does not prove free disposal
To seize assets held by a trust or by interposed companies, on the ground that the person under investigation has free disposal of them, it is not enough to assert that he is the trust's « beneficial owner ». The French Cour de cassation requires concrete proof that the trust, or the company holding the asset, is only an apparent owner, based on how the trust actually operates or on the powers actually exercised over the asset. What the ruling changes for settlors, beneficiaries and trustees, and how to prepare.
Can a French criminal judge seize trust assets solely because the person under investigation is the trust's beneficial owner?
No. In the case decided, the funds seized legally belonged to a group company, not to the person under investigation: seizing them required that he have free disposal of them, subject to the rights of an owner acting in good faith. Yet the status of « beneficial owner » under article 1649 AB of the French Tax Code does not only cover the person who controls the trust: it also covers the natural persons acting as trustee, settlor, beneficiary or protector. On its own, it cannot establish free disposal of the trust assets (Cass. crim., 4 November 2026, no. 25-80.115, published in the Bulletin).
The judge must show that the person is the economic owner of the assets and that the trust, or the company holding them, is only their apparent legal owner, interposed to conceal the reality. That proof may be drawn, in particular, from how the trust actually operates or from the exercise of management or disposal powers over the assets.
Cass. crim., 4 November 2026, no. 25-80.115; French Criminal Code, art. 131-21; French Code of Criminal Procedure, art. 706-153; French Tax Code, art. 1649 AB. Texts as in force on 11 November 2026.
- What was held
- Beneficial ownership of a trust (French Tax Code, art. 1649 AB) does not, on its own, prove free disposal of its assets
- What is required
- Concrete evidence that the trust or the company is only an apparent owner
- Also held
- A third-party company's good faith cannot be set aside on the basis of distinct facts, unless the link is shown
- Who is concerned
- Settlors, beneficiaries, protectors and trustees of trusts holding assets in France
Beneficial owner and free disposal: two distinct concepts
The Court recalls that, under articles 131-21 of the Criminal Code and 706-153 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, an asset or intangible right liable to confiscation of assets may be seized if it belongs to the person under investigation or if that person has free disposal of it, subject to the rights of a good-faith owner. Confiscation by value may likewise be enforced against assets freely at the person's disposal, subject to the same reservation (Criminal Code, art. 131-21). Other grounds, such as confiscation of the object or proceeds of the offence, are subject to their own conditions. The investigating chamber had treated free disposal as established because the person was the trust's beneficial owner.
The Cour de cassation rejects that shortcut. Article 1649 AB of the Tax Code, as amended by the ordinance of 12 February 2020, defines the beneficial owners of a trust as all natural persons acting as trustee, settlor, beneficiary and, where applicable, protector, as well as any other person exercising effective control. It is a broad tax concept, designed for trust reporting obligations: several people may be beneficial owners of the same trust without any of them having free disposal of its assets. Even combined with the fact that the person was the insured life under the policy of which the trust was the beneficiary, it is not enough.
The Court states what the judge must establish. Either that the person is the economic owner of the trust, the trust being only the apparent legal owner, interposed to conceal the reality of ownership, using evidence that may be drawn in particular from an analysis of how the trust actually operates. Or that the person is the economic owner of the asset itself, the company holding it being only its apparent legal owner, in particular through evidence relating to the holding or exercise of management or disposal powers over that asset.
The company's good faith and the amount seized
- The third-party owner's good faith. To set aside the good faith of the company owning the seized claim, the investigating chamber had relied on its sham nature and its role as an interposed entity. The Court holds that these grounds could not establish lack of good faith, since they related to tax fraud and money laundering facts distinct from those alleged against the person under investigation, and it had not been shown that they could extend to them.
- The ceiling of the seizure. The investigating chamber had to ensure that the claim seized did not exceed the proceeds or object of the alleged offences. To check this, it took into account a release of funds that had been seized not as the value of the proceeds or object of the offences, but under a seizure of assets. The Court holds the decision insufficiently reasoned: the ceiling of the value-based seizure could not be checked by reference to a release made under a seizure of assets.
Tax and criminal law: two burdens of proof that must not be confused
In tax matters, the burden of proof may rest on the taxpayer. On 13 March 2026 (no. 500318), the Conseil d'État held that trust income is taxable as investment income only if the beneficiary actually has it at his disposal, but that, when characterising payments received from a trust under article 120 of the Tax Code, it is for the taxpayer alone to produce evidence that they are not distributions of income. See our analysis (in French).
In criminal seizure proceedings, by contrast, the Cour de cassation requires the judge to show free disposal concretely. The trust's tax filings, which name its beneficial owners under article 1649 AB, do not on their own prove control of the assets; they remain one element among others. The same structure is therefore defended with different evidence depending on the forum: in tax matters, the traceability and nature of the payments; in criminal matters, how the trust and the companies it holds actually operate.
What to document, before any proceedings
The ruling rejects abstract reasoning; it does not protect trusts whose operation reveals real control by the settlor or a beneficiary. Proof turns on facts. The recommendations below reflect our practice: they are not stated by the ruling, and each structure must be reviewed in the light of its documents and governing law.
- Trustee decisions. Dated, reasoned resolutions taken by the trustee itself, for distributions as well as for transactions on the underlying assets. A trustee that executes instructions without reviewing them supports the apparent-owner argument.
- Letter of wishes and reserved powers. A letter of wishes generally expresses wishes that the trustee takes into account without being bound by them; its effect depends on its wording and on the law governing the trust. Powers reserved to the settlor or conferred on the protector should match the trust deed and be exercised within those limits.
- Underlying companies. The Court refers to the exercise of management or disposal powers over the assets. Who signs on the accounts, who decides on sales, who instructs the directors of the companies held: that is where the judge will look.
- Consistent filings. Article 1649 AB filings, beneficial ownership registers, bank documentation and life insurance policies should tell the same story. Inconsistencies are exploited, as in the case decided, where the intention attributed to the life insurance policies was in dispute.
- Act quickly if assets are seized. The seizure order is notified to the owner and to known third parties with rights over the asset, who may refer it to the investigating chamber within ten days of notification. The appeal does not suspend the seizure (Code of Criminal Procedure, art. 706-153).
The case
A judicial investigation was opened, in particular for aggravated tax fraud and money laundering. A group of Danish and French companies, held by a Luxembourg company, sold numerous buildings; according to the French tax authorities, these sales gave rise to no tax in France. The person under formal investigation was suspected of indirectly owning the whole structure. He had held the shares of the Luxembourg parent company, which were transferred in 2005 to a Jersey family trust, then assigned in 2006, by way of payment in kind under a life insurance policy, to a Luxembourg company; the trust was reportedly the policyholder and beneficiary of the policy, and the person under investigation the insured life.
The liberty and custody judge ordered the seizure, in the hands of a notary, of funds arising from the sale of a building by one of the group's French companies. The investigating chamber of the Paris Court of Appeal upheld the order: since the person was the beneficial owner of the trust, itself the beneficiary of the life insurance policy, and the sole insured life, he was the ultimate economic beneficiary of the companies and therefore had free disposal of the funds seized.
On appeal by the company whose claim had been seized, the Cour de cassation quashed the judgment in its entirety and remitted the case to the Paris investigating chamber, differently composed.
How the firm assists you
The firm reviews how trusts holding assets in France, or with beneficiaries resident in France, actually operate: deeds, trustee decisions, reserved powers, tax filings. It coordinates the defence with trustees and foreign advisers, and handles the tax side of proceedings, working with criminal defence counsel where proceedings are criminal.
The firm's trust and fiducie practice is led by Jonathan Bensaid and Lauren Bensaid, holder of the university diploma (DU) in fiducie. Members of the Paris and Geneva bars, working in French and English.
Trusts and criminal seizure: your questions
Does being reported as a trust's beneficial owner expose one's assets to seizure?
Not on its own. The Cour de cassation holds that beneficial ownership under article 1649 AB of the French Tax Code, which also covers the natural persons acting as trustee, settlor, beneficiary or protector, is not enough to establish free disposal of the trust assets (Cass. crim., 4 November 2026, no. 25-80.115).
What must the judge prove to seize assets held by a trust?
Where the assets legally belong to a third party, as in the case decided: that the person under investigation is the economic owner of the assets, the trust or the holding company being only their apparent legal owner, interposed to conceal the reality. That proof may be drawn from how the trust actually operates or from the exercise of management or disposal powers over the assets. The rights of a good-faith owner also remain reserved: the Court separately quashed the reasoning on the company's good faith.
Does the ruling protect every trust?
It protects against abstract reasoning, not against facts. A trust in which the settlor or a beneficiary in reality decides everything may still be treated as an apparent owner. Protection depends on how the trust operates and on what can be shown.
Can a company held through a trust rely on its good faith?
Yes. The rights of a good-faith owner are reserved by article 131-21 of the French Criminal Code. In this case, the Cour de cassation held that grounds drawn from facts distinct from those alleged against the person under investigation were not enough to set aside that good faith, absent a showing that they could extend to the facts under investigation.
How long is there to challenge a seizure order?
The seizure order is notified to the owner of the asset and to known third parties with rights over it, who may refer it to the investigating chamber within ten days of notification. The appeal does not suspend the seizure (Code of Criminal Procedure, art. 706-153).
Further reading
French tax traps for Jersey trustees
Reporting, annual levy and transfers.
Voir la page Criminal tax lawCriminal tax law in France
Tax fraud, money laundering and criminal procedure.
Voir la page PracticeFiduciary lawyer
French fiducie and foreign trusts.
Voir la page In FrenchTrust et saisie pénale
The French version of this analysis.
Voir la pageSecuring a trust or challenging a seizure? Let us talk today.
The information on this page is provided for information purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. It does not address any foreign law. Source: Cass. crim., 4 November 2026, no. 25-80.115. Law as at 11 November 2026.